Banquet OCT is committed to transparency and clarity in our evaluation process for auditions and entries. We strictly adhere to the Judging Rubric, ensuring that 99% of critiques are firmly based on objective criteria supported by examples and evidence. The remaining 1% is reserved for instances of ties, where our own subjective opinions will guide our decision-making. All assessments will be meticulously documented, eliminating any ambiguity surrounding our selection criteria.

Furthermore, every entry will undergo a comprehensive review process. ONLY ON REQUEST will our judges will precisely outline the strengths and weaknesses in graphics and composition, offering specific suggestions and examples for improvement. These editorial reviews will primarily highlight areas for refinement, assuming that any aspects not addressed are considered adequate unless executed flawlessly. This approach forms the foundation of our critique process.

If you wish for a critique of your work, please state what precisely about what aspect you’d like your crit to focus on upon submission. The audition submission form is here.

It’s important to note that our approach to critique is focused on substance rather than mere praise. We value constructive feedback over the ‘compliment sandwich’ approach. As an OCT geared towards adults, we expect contestants to engage maturely in this process. Our objective is mutual improvement, and we encourage seeking compliments from friends and family, recognizing our role in fostering growth through constructive criticism.

​

Questions or Concerns? Please contact us in the Discord, email, or through Twitter DM!